| Champion |
Defeated |
Event Won |
Successful
Title Defenses |
| Shawn Michaels |
Alan Matthews |
November 2 Dismember 2011 |
0
|
| Alan Matthews |
Troy Joseph |
Halloween Hellraiser 2011 |
0
|
| Troy Joseph |
Alan Matthews |
Glory 2011 |
0
|
|
Alan Matthews
|
Benjamin J. Franklin |
Summertime Blowout 2011 |
0
|
| Benjamin J. Franklin |
Troy Joseph |
Beach Brawl 2011 |
0
|
| Troy Joseph |
DDP |
Sabotage 2011 |
3
|
| Diamond Dallas Page |
AJ Styles |
May-Hem 2010 |
8
|
| AJ Styles |
DDP |
Unholy Alliances 2010 |
1
|
| Diamond Dallas Page |
Troy Joseph |
Vendetta 2010 |
0
|
| Troy Joseph |
Lone Jobber |
Summertime Blowout 2009 |
9
|
| Lone Jobber |
Josh Stewart |
Unholy Alliances 2009 |
6
|
| Josh Stewart |
Subway |
Thursday Night Chaos 1-22-09 |
3 |
| Subway |
Darien Hacaga |
Friday Night Frenzy 10-10-08 |
4 |
| Darien Hacaga |
J-Twisted |
Glory 2008 |
0 |
| J-Twisted |
Chris Jericho |
Beach Brawl 2008 |
3 |
| Chris Jericho |
Shawn Michaels |
High Stakes 2008 |
2 |
| ^Shawn Michaels |
Justin Credible |
Tuesday Night Carnage 06-10-08 |
1 |
| Michael Kruel |
James Storm |
May-Hem 2008 |
0 |
| James Storm |
Dante Daevain |
Tuesday Night Carnage 05-20-08 |
0 |
| Dante Daevain |
Shawn Michaels |
Friday Night Frenzy 05-09-08 |
0 |
| Shawn Michaels |
Josh Stewart |
Unholy Alliances 2008 |
0 |
| Josh Stewart |
Christian Taylor |
Friday Night Frenzy
03-21-08 |
2 |
| Christian Taylor |
Dangerous D |
Tuesday Night Carnage
03-11-08 |
1 |
| Dangerous D |
Justin Credible |
Tuesday Night Carnage
02-12-08 |
2 |
| Justin Credible |
Jason Phoenix |
Thursday Night Chaos
1-10-08 |
2 |
| #Jason Phoenix |
Lance Hoyt |
November 2 Dismember 2007 |
3 |
| Shawn Michaels |
Purgatory |
Any Given Sunday 2002 |
2 |
| *Purgatory |
Battle Royal |
Tournament of Champions 2002 |
8 |
